
Key Person vs Relevant Life vs Shareholder Protection: Which Does Your Business Need?
Which business protection policy does your business need? It depends on what you're protecting. Relevant life insurance protects your family, key person insurance protects the company's profits, and shareholder protection protects who owns the business. Limited companies with more than one owner often need all three, because each one pays a different person for a different reason.
Key facts
- Relevant life insurance pays a tax-free lump sum to a director's family through a trust if the director dies.
- Key person insurance pays the company if a key individual dies or, where added, suffers a critical illness.
- Shareholder protection gives the surviving owners the funds to buy a deceased shareholder's shares.
- Relevant life premiums get corporation tax relief with no benefit-in-kind charge (HMRC EIM15045).
How do the three business protection policies compare?
Side by side, it's easy to see where the three policies part ways.
Sources: HMRC EIM15045 and BIM45525; Executive Life. Cover limits vary by insurer.
What does relevant life insurance do?
Relevant life is personal life cover paid for by your company. If you die, a tax-free lump sum goes to your family through a trust, outside your estate for inheritance tax. The company claims corporation tax relief on the premiums and, under HMRC's EIM15045 guidance, there's no benefit-in-kind charge for you.
Because the premiums come from the company rather than your taxed income, a higher-rate director saves £132.52 of company profit a month for every £100 of premium, as our relevant life tax benefits guide shows (2026/27 rates). Relevant life is only available through an employer, so sole traders can't use it.
What does key person insurance do?
Key person insurance protects the business itself. If someone the company relies on dies or becomes seriously ill, the payout replaces lost profit, funds recruitment and keeps lenders on side. The person insured doesn't need to own shares, and the company is the only beneficiary.
Cover is usually set at five to ten times the key person's remuneration, and key person cover can also include critical illness, the one gap relevant life can't fill, as our guide to critical illness cover for business owners explains.
What does shareholder protection do?
Shareholder protection protects ownership. When a shareholder dies, their shares pass to their estate, often to family with no role in the business. Shareholder protection gives the surviving owners the money to buy those shares at a fair value, so control stays with the people running the company.
Usually, the company takes out and owns a policy on each shareholder's life, written in trust for the other owners, backed by a cross option agreement that makes the sale binding once the cover pays out.
Alternatively, the company can keep the payout and buy the shares back itself, which our company share buyback guide covers in detail.
Which combination does your business need?
Start with who would be hurt most if a director died or fell seriously ill. The table matches common situations to the policy that deals with each one.
Source: Executive Life.
For a company with several owners, that usually means all three working together. Our multiple directors page shows how they fit around a typical director team.
If you're the only shareholder, shareholder protection doesn't apply, and relevant life and key person cover usually do the heavy lifting. Our single director page covers that set up.
Executive Life is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 985058). We look at all three together rather than one at a time, and you can request a quote in around 60 seconds.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between relevant life and key person insurance?
Relevant life insurance pays a director's family through a trust if the director dies. Key person insurance pays the company if a key individual dies or becomes seriously ill. The company pays the premiums for both.
Can one director be covered by all three policies?
Yes. A director who owns shares and drives profits can hold all three at once, with each policy paying a different beneficiary.
Does a single director company need shareholder protection?
No. Shareholder protection funds co-owners to buy a deceased shareholder's shares, so it doesn't apply when there's only one shareholder. A single director usually focuses on relevant life and key person cover.
Do all three policies qualify for corporation tax relief?
Relevant life premiums qualify for corporation tax relief. Key person premiums generally qualify when the policy protects trading profit. Shareholder protection premiums usually qualify too, but company-paid policies in trust create a benefit-in-kind charge for each shareholder.
Can relevant life insurance include critical illness cover?
No. Relevant life insurance only pays out on death, and on terminal illness with most insurers. Key person insurance and shareholder protection can both include critical illness cover.
Last reviewed: October 2026. Next review: April 2027. Tax rates and thresholds are subject to change. This article will be updated following each HMRC Autumn Budget or Spring Statement where relevant thresholds change.
This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may be subject to change. Always seek professional advice before making financial decisions.
Written by
Alex Ogden DipFA | Director | Executive Life
Alex Ogden DipFA holds the Level 4 Diploma for Financial Advisers (DipFA) awarded by the Walbrook Institute London, formerly known as the London Institute of Banking & Finance (LIBF), the FCA's benchmark qualification for retail investment advisers. He is authorised by the FCA, Ref: AJO01072. View the FCA register entry.

