
How to Value Shares in a Private Limited Company
How do you value shares in a private limited company? Usually by valuing the whole company, then splitting that value by each shareholder's percentage. For most profitable trading companies the starting point is an earnings multiple: maintainable profit multiplied by a sector multiple, often three to six times for a small owner managed business, then adjusted for cash and debt. Net asset value suits asset heavy companies, and dividend yield is used less often.
There's no stock exchange price, so the value always depends on the method and assumptions used. That's why agreeing a method in advance matters, especially for shareholder protection insurance, where each policy should match the current value of each stake.
Key facts
- Private company shares have no market price, so their value depends on the valuation method used.
- The earnings multiple method is the most common for profitable trading companies, often three to six times maintainable profit for small owner managed businesses.
- Net asset value suits property and investment companies, where the value sits on the balance sheet.
- For shareholder protection, each policy's sum assured should match the current value of the insured shareholder's stake.
Why is valuing private company shares so subjective?
Because two people can apply different methods to the same accounts and both be reasonable. A seller leans towards the method that gives the highest figure and a buyer towards the lowest. Even HMRC keeps a whole Shares and Assets Valuation Manual for valuing unquoted shares for tax purposes.
What are the main ways to value a private company?
Four methods cover most situations. The table applies each one to the same example company, with £300,000 of maintainable profit (EBITDA), £2 million of revenue, £600,000 of net assets and £120,000 of annual dividends.
Illustrative example only. Earnings multiple of 4 with £150,000 surplus cash and £100,000 debt; revenue multiple of 0.6; required dividend yield of 12%.
How does the earnings multiple method work?
Start with maintainable earnings: profit adjusted for one-off costs and for directors' pay above or below a market rate. Multiply by a figure that reflects the sector, size, risk and growth prospects, then add surplus cash and deduct debt. In the example, £300,000 × 4 gives £1.2 million, plus £150,000 of cash, less £100,000 of debt, which comes to £1.25 million.
When is net asset value the better method?
Net asset value works best when the value sits on the balance sheet rather than in future profits, such as a property or investment company. For service businesses and professional practices it usually understates the company, because the real value is in people, clients and earnings.
How much is each shareholder's stake worth?
For shareholder protection, the usual approach is a straight percentage of the whole company value. Using the £1.25 million earnings multiple value from our example, the stakes and suggested cover look like this.
Illustrative example only, based on a company value of £1,250,000.
How should the valuation method be agreed for shareholder protection?
The method should be written into your shareholders' agreement or cross option agreement before any cover is arranged. Without an agreed method, the surviving owners and the family start negotiating from scratch at the worst possible time.
Source: Executive Life.
For most small companies, an earnings multiple formula works well, because it moves with the business and your accountant can confirm it each year.
How often should the valuation and cover be reviewed?
At least once a year, usually when the annual accounts are signed off, and whenever the business value or shareholdings change significantly. If our example company grows to £2 million, shareholder A's 50% stake is worth £1 million against £625,000 of cover, leaving the survivors £375,000 short.
The agreement itself matters as much as the number. A cross option agreement, rather than a binding buy-sell agreement, helps preserve inheritance tax relief on the shares, as our guide to shareholder protection and Business Property Relief explains.
Executive Life is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 985058). We help shareholders agree a valuation basis and match cover to it, and you can request a shareholder protection quote in around 60 seconds.
Frequently asked questions
What is the most common way to value shares in a private limited company?
The earnings multiple method is the most common. Maintainable profit is multiplied by a sector multiple, adjusted for cash and debt, and the result is split by each shareholder's percentage.
What multiple is used to value a small business?
Small owner managed businesses are often valued at three to six times maintainable EBITDA, depending on sector, size, risk and growth. Your accountant or a valuer can suggest a multiple based on comparable deals.
Should a minority shareholding be valued at a discount?
For a sale or a tax valuation, a minority stake is often discounted because it carries less control. Shareholder protection agreements usually value each stake as a straight share of the whole company, with no discount.
Who values the shares for shareholder protection?
The shareholders agree the method, usually with their accountant, and record it in the cross option agreement. Some agreements use an independent valuer instead.
How often should shareholder protection cover be updated?
Shareholder protection cover should be reviewed at least once a year and whenever the company's value or shareholdings change. Increases in cover are underwritten at your current age and health.
Last reviewed: October 2026. Next review: April 2027. Tax rates and thresholds are subject to change. This article will be updated following each HMRC Autumn Budget or Spring Statement where relevant thresholds change.
This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may be subject to change. Always seek professional advice before making financial decisions.
Written by
Alex Ogden DipFA | Director | Executive Life
Alex Ogden DipFA holds the Level 4 Diploma for Financial Advisers (DipFA) awarded by the Walbrook Institute London, formerly known as the London Institute of Banking & Finance (LIBF), the FCA's benchmark qualification for retail investment advisers. He is authorised by the FCA, Ref: AJO01072. View the FCA register entry.

