Most business owners know, instinctively, who their key person is. It’s the person whose name comes to mind immediately when you ask yourself: if they weren’t here tomorrow, what would happen to the business?
For some directors that person is themselves. For others it’s a co-director, a lead salesperson, or a technical specialist the whole operation depends on. Whoever it is, the question is worth sitting with, because most businesses haven’t thought through what the financial impact would actually look like, and the reality is more serious than people expect.
The immediate financial hit
The first thing that happens when a key person dies is a revenue problem. If they were responsible for client relationships, those clients are suddenly uncertain about who they’re dealing with and whether the service they rely on will continue. Some will wait and see. Others will start looking elsewhere immediately. Either way, the business is managing a revenue risk at exactly the moment it’s also dealing with the human impact of losing someone.
If the key person was a salesperson or business developer, the pipeline they were building disappears with them. Deals in progress stall. Relationships that hadn’t yet converted go cold. The revenue that would have landed over the next six to twelve months simply doesn’t.
And then comes the cost of replacing them. Senior recruitment doesn’t happen quickly or cheaply. Search fees for experienced hires regularly run to 20-30% of annual salary. Add the time for a new person to become fully productive, which is often twelve months or more for a genuinely senior role, and the financial gap between losing a key person and getting back to full strength is significant.
The lender problem
Many business owners don’t think about this until it happens to someone they know and by then, it’s too late to do anything about it.
Business loans, overdraft facilities, and credit lines are frequently underwritten against the personal guarantees and credentials of key individuals within the business. When one of those individuals dies, the lender’s exposure changes. They have the right to review the facility and in some cases they exercise it. A credit line that was available last week may be frozen this week, at the exact moment the business needs financial flexibility to get through the transition.
Raising new finance in the aftermath isn’t straightforward either. Lenders want to see stability and continuity. A business that has just lost a key person doesn’t present either of those things in the short term. The business finds itself trying to access capital from a position of weakness rather than strength.
The ownership problem: if the key person was also a shareholder
This is where the situation can move from difficult to genuinely serious.
If the person who died held shares in the business, those shares don’t disappear. They pass to whoever inherits their estate, typically a spouse or family member who had no involvement in the business and may never have met the other directors professionally. That person now owns a stake in a company they didn’t build, don’t understand, and may have very different ideas about.
They have the right to receive dividends. They have voting rights. And they have no legal obligation to sell – not quickly, not at a fair price, and not at all if they choose not to.
The surviving directors are simultaneously trying to manage a business through a difficult period and navigate an ownership situation they never planned for. The two problems compound each other in ways that can be genuinely destabilising.
This is a separate risk to the financial impact of losing a key person and it requires a separate solution. Key person insurance addresses the financial loss. Shareholder protection addresses the ownership question. For director-owned businesses where the key person is also a shareholder, both matter.
The planning gap
The uncomfortable truth is that most small and medium-sized businesses have no funded plan in place for the loss of a key person. They have good intentions, they’ve thought about it in the abstract, but they haven’t converted that awareness into an arrangement that actually does something when the worst happens.
Without a plan, the business is left managing the financial impact from its own resources, at the worst possible time, under the worst possible pressure, with the least possible clarity. Directors who have spent years building something find themselves fighting to hold it together rather than growing it.
With a plan, the picture looks completely different.
What changes when you have the right cover in place
A key person insurance policy pays a lump sum directly to the business when a key individual dies or suffers a serious critical illness. That money doesn’t replace the person, nothing does, but it gives the business the financial breathing room to get through the transition without the pressure becoming terminal.
It covers lost revenue while a replacement is found. It funds the recruitment and training costs without raiding working capital. It removes the lender’s ability to review facilities at a moment of vulnerability. And it gives the surviving directors the one thing they need most in a crisis, which is time to make good decisions rather than reactive ones.
If the key person was also a shareholder, a shareholder protection arrangement running alongside the key person policy means the ownership question is resolved cleanly too. The shares are bought back at an agreed price, the family receives a fair payment, and the business remains in the hands of the people who built it.
Neither arrangement is complicated to put in place. Both are significantly easier to arrange now — when everyone is well, when the business is stable, and when there’s no pressure — than in the aftermath of a loss.
If you haven’t looked at either yet, the place to start is understanding what cover would actually cost for your specific business and your specific key people.
Our insights
Read our collection of insights and blogs to find out what other business owners and the industry is doing.
